Margin-First Marketplace Expansion

Margin-First Marketplace Expansion

From Buy Box instability to 137% year-over-year growth: How we stabilized illy's marketplace presence with operational discipline, defended premium positioning, and unlocked compounding scale without discounting.

From Buy Box instability to 137% year-over-year growth: How we stabilized illy's marketplace presence with operational discipline, defended premium positioning, and unlocked compounding scale without discounting.

+137%

+137%

YoY Growth in Classico Capsules

YoY Growth in Classico Capsules

YoY Growth in Classico Capsules

+137%

+137%

YoY After Buy Box Recovery

YoY After Buy Box Recovery

YoY After Buy Box Recovery

+31%

+31%

Buy Box Ownership Recovery

Buy Box Ownership Recovery

Buy Box Ownership Recovery

“Neato restored control to our marketplace business in one of the most competitive grocery categories. With a successful Buy Box stabilization plan in place, paid media became strategic, and capsules scaled. They understand premium brands.”

Strategy Snapshot

The breakthrough came from Buy Box stabilization. We aligned pricing enforcement, inventory health, and campaign segmentation to defend branded search. With ownership restored, capsule lines saw accelerated growth without discounting — preserving premium positioning while unlocking scale.

The Challenge

illy is a premium global coffee brand. But premium positioning is fragile on Amazon. Neato operates as illy's seller of record — which means Buy Box instability wasn't a client reporting problem. It was our revenue problem. We don't advise on Buy Box recovery. We recover it.

The Classico Aluminum Capsule line faced Buy Box instability, pricing inconsistency, fragmented traffic allocation, and margin pressure. When Buy Box ownership slips, growth stalls.

The Opportunity

Capsules represent high repeat purchase behavior, strong branded search volume, and predictable replenishment cycles. If Buy Box ownership could be stabilized, compounding growth was possible.

The Strategy

1. Buy Box Recovery & Stabilization We aligned pricing enforcement, inventory health, and reseller containment. Buy Box ownership improved significantly, restoring traffic capture.

2. Branded Search Defense We aggressively protected high-intent branded terms while eliminating wasteful generic traffic. Premium brands win by defending intent — not by discounting.

3. Margin-First Campaign Segmentation Capsule variants were segmented by roast intensity to prevent overlap and maximize conversion clarity.

“Neato restored control to our marketplace business in one of the most competitive grocery categories."

The Results

+137% YoY Revenue Growth

No heavy discounting.

No race to the bottom.

+29 pt Buy Box Improvement

+4 pt CVR Lift Sustained Premium Pricing

Why It Worked

Amazon rewards operational stability. And Neato is structured to deliver it — because as the retailer, we're the ones absorbing the cost when it slips. There's no version of this story where we let Buy Box instability persist. When we stabilized Buy Box ownership, everything compounded: Conversion. Rank. Reorder velocity. Margin preservation.

The Takeaway

Premium brands don't need to discount to scale. They need control.

Brand Name

Illy Coffee

Illy Coffee

Brand Size

Large

Large

Brand Industry

Coffee

Coffee

About

Mid-sized

Mid-sized

More Case Studies

No packages. No add-ons. No surprise fees.

Ready to see if 2P fits your brand?

Let's talk about your Amazon operation

We buy your inventory, own the P&L, and operate Amazon end-to-end, so your growth isn’t dependent on an agency or internal team.

© 2026 Neato. All rights reserved.

No packages. No add-ons. No surprise fees.

Ready to see if 2P fits your brand?

Let's talk about your Amazon operation

We buy your inventory, own the P&L, and operate Amazon end-to-end, so your growth isn’t dependent on an agency or internal team.

© 2026 Neato. All rights reserved.

No packages. No add-ons. No surprise fees.

Ready to see if 2P fits your brand?

Let's talk about your Amazon operation

We buy your inventory, own the P&L, and operate Amazon end-to-end, so your growth isn’t dependent on an agency or internal team.

© 2026 Neato. All rights reserved.